Capacity building for cancer prevention and early detection in the Ugandan primary healthcare facilities: Working toward reducing the unmet needs of cancer control services

listen audio

Study Justification:
– In Uganda, there is a high prevalence of cancer and a low level of cancer health literacy in the population.
– Only 5% of cancer patients in Uganda have access to cancer care, and 77% present with late-stage cancer.
– The study aimed to contribute to reducing the unmet needs of cancer prevention and early detection services in Uganda through capacity building.
Study Highlights:
– Two national and six regional cancer control stakeholders’ consultative meetings were conducted in 2017.
– District primary healthcare teams were trained on cancer prevention and early detection in 2017 and 2018.
– Cancer information materials for health workers and communities were developed and distributed to 122 districts.
– Health workers in the pilot East-central subregion were further trained in cervical, breast, and prostate cancer early detection techniques.
– Follow-up after the training indicated that 75% of the districts had implemented at least one of the proposed actions.
Recommendations for Lay Reader and Policy Maker:
– Building the capacity of primary healthcare workers to integrate cancer prevention and early detection into primary health care can help reduce the unmet needs of cancer control services in Uganda.
– Emphasizing low-cost options for low-income countries, such as visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) or Papanicolaou (Pap) smear test for cervical screening and clinical breast examination (CBE) for breast screening.
– Public health education on early warning cancer symptoms and signs to facilitate early diagnosis and treatment.
– Collaboration between stakeholders, including district health officers, chief administrative officers, district local council members, and civil society organizations, is crucial for the successful implementation of cancer prevention and early detection programs.
Key Role Players:
– District health officers
– Chief administrative officers
– District local council members
– Civil society organizations
– Health workers
– Village health teams
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations (Budget Items):
– Training materials development and distribution
– Training sessions for district primary healthcare teams
– Development and dissemination of cancer information materials
– Equipment and supplies for cancer screening in pilot districts
– Audiovisual clips development for mass and social media dissemination
– Follow-up activities in the districts
Please note that the provided information is based on the given description and publication.

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is moderately strong, but there are areas for improvement. The abstract provides information on the methods used, the number of participants trained, and the development and distribution of cancer information materials. However, it lacks specific details on the outcomes and impact of the capacity building efforts. To improve the evidence, the abstract could include data on the effectiveness of the training in terms of improved cancer prevention and early detection rates, as well as any changes in cancer health literacy in the population. Additionally, including information on the follow-up evaluation and its findings would strengthen the evidence further.

Background: In 2018, approximately 60,000 Ugandans were estimated to be suffering from cancer. It was also reported that only 5% of cancer patients access cancer care and 77% present with late-stage cancer coupled with low level of cancer health literacy in the population despite a wide coverage of primary healthcare facilities in Uganda. We aimed to contribute to reducing the unmet needs of cancer prevention and early detection services in Uganda through capacity building. Methods: In 2017, we conducted two national and six regional cancer control stakeholders’ consultative meetings. In 2017 and 2018, we trained district primary healthcare teams on cancer prevention and early detection. We also developed cancer information materials for health workers and communities and conducted a follow-up after the training. Results: A total of 488 primary healthcare workers from 118 districts were trained. Forty-six health workers in the pilot East-central subregion were further trained in cervical, breast, and prostate cancer early detection (screening and early diagnosis) techniques. A total of 32,800 cancer information, education and communication materials; breast, cervical, prostate childhood and general cancer information booklets; health education guide, community cancer information flipcharts for village health teams and referral guidelines for suspected cancer were developed and distributed to 122 districts. Also, 16 public and private-not-for-profit regional hospitals, and one training institution received these materials. Audiovisual clips on breast, cervical, and prostate cancer were developed for mass and social media dissemination. A follow-up after six months to one year indicated that 75% of the districts had implemented at least one of the agreed actions proposed during the training. Conclusions: In Uganda, the unmet needs for cancer control services are enormous. However, building the capacity of primary healthcare workers to integrate prevention and early detection of cancer into primary health care based on low-cost options for low-income countries could contribute to reducing the unmet needs of cancer prevention and early detection in Uganda.

This capacity building efforts to integrate primary prevention and early detection of cancer into the existing PHC facilities involved stakeholders’ consultative meetings, development and distribution of cancer reference IEC materials for health workers and communities, training of district PHC workers and follow‐up. We targeted all the 122 districts in Uganda based on number of districts in Uganda as in 2017. The participants were sampled purposively with specified inclusion criteria. Invitation letters were emailed to the district health officers to mobilize the specified category of district leaders who were willing to participate in the regional level consultation meetings. Invitation letters were also emailed to the district health officer to identify four health workers who were willing to be trained. In 2017, we mobilized and conducted one‐day 6 regional cancer control stakeholders’ consultative meetings with representation from 118 out of the planned 122 districts (Table ​(Table11 and Figure ​Figure1).1). A maximum of 4 participants per district were invited. The stakeholders included were the District health officers (DHOs)‐head of district health services, Chief administrative officers (CAOs)‐head of district technical services, Chairperson district local council V (CPLCV)‐political head of the district local government, and member of the civil society organizations (CSOs)‐Non‐governmental health related program implementers and advocates. This was done to get input on what is needed and to advocate for their local leadership support for the inclusion of primary prevention and early detection of cancer in their district health work plans. The narrated view points and recommendations of the stakeholders were captured “as said” through note taking and audio‐recording to inform the subsequent capacity building process and interventions. Regional cancer control stakeholders’ consultative meetings, 2017, Uganda. No. of districts Represented Map of Uganda showing the regions, subregions, and districts where the district stakeholders’ meetings and training of PHC workers were conducted. Adapted from: Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS). In this map, Western region = Western and South Western, Northern = Acholi, West Nile and Lango, Eastern region = East‐central, Elgon, Teso and Karamoja. During the capacity building activities, Acholi, Lango, and Karamoja were zoned as Northern region and North‐western districts zoned with West Nile. We developed print and audiovisual cancer education, information and communication (IEC) materials on prevention, early detection and referral based on the commonest types of cancer in Uganda. We reviewed published literatures including World health organization (WHO) publications to guide the development of these IEC materials. These materials were developed to provide reference information for the health workers and community village health teams (VHTs) with priority on the most common types of cancer in Uganda‐especially cervical, breast, and prostate cancer. In 2017 and 2018, a maximum of four PHC workers per district were invited for training. The district health teams included were the assistant district health officer‐in‐charge maternal and child health, medical officer or clinical officer, nursing officer and health educator per district and were selected by the district health management from 122 planned districts. The districts were zoned into 6 regions: West Nile, Central, East‐central, Eastern, Western, and Northern Uganda (Figure ​(Figure11). The district PHC workers were intensively trained for five days on cancer primary prevention and early detection including raising cancer awareness in the communities, promotion of human papillomavirus and hepatitis B vaccination, early detection through early diagnosis and screening strategies, referral and community‐based care. Emphasis was put on the most common types of cancer in Uganda: cervical, breast, prostate, Kaposi sarcoma, esophageal, liver, lymphoma, leukemia, colo‐rectal, and childhood cancers. In cancer screening pilot districts in East‐central subregion, 46 health workers from 10 health facilities were further intensively trained for 10 days and equipped to provide routine cancer screening for the most common types of cancer in Uganda. The early detection training component focused on low‐cost options for low‐ and middle‐income countries. For cervical screening, we emphasized visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) or Papanicolaou (Pap) smear test and pre‐cancer treatment using cryotherapy or thermocoagulation based on “see and treat” or “see and see and treat” approaches. VIA screening is still the most feasible option in low‐income countries and could still be conducive to the future introduction of HPV screening. 18 Prostate screening methods were based on prostate‐specific antigen (PSA) blood test and digital rectal examination (DRE) technique for most at risk men. 19 , 20 The affordable option for breast screening at district PHC facilities in Uganda was clinical breast examination (CBE) and demonstrating to women self‐breast examination (SBE) technique as part of early diagnosis strategy—not screening. Clients with abnormal or suspicious findings in their breast were to be recommended for or referred for breast ultrasound scan or mammography where applicable. However, it is crucial to reiterate that mammography screening option is complex and resource‐intensive, thus may not be feasible in health‐resources constrained countries. 17 , 18 , 21 Mammography is also reported as being less sensitive in young African women and other women with dense breast tissue. 3 For all types of cancer amenable by early detection, we focused on public health education on early warning cancer symptoms and signs to facilitate seeking early diagnosis and treatment. During the training, in early detection of cancer we emphasized the application of a low‐cost options of raising cancer awareness and early detection in the communities from lowest level community health facilities through the health service delivery hierarchies, similar to the recent “step‐wise five components” model that was tested in Peru in the context of low‐ and middle‐income countries. 17 This involves 1‐health education to raise awareness on risk factors, early warning symptoms and signs, and need for screening; 2‐clinical or laboratory‐based screening in a primary healthcare setting; 3‐triage for imaging or laboratory test for detected or suspected lesions or other abnormality during a clinical examination; and 4‐referral of clients with positive or cancer suspicious findings for further management in tertiary hospitals. 17 We used interactive lectures, demonstration and returned demonstration, role plays and group discussion as the main teaching and learning methods. We assessed learning progress through pre‐ and post‐tests based on a set of questions that covered the entire training content. We also conducted a follow‐up in the districts after six months to approximately one year after the training—as part of process evaluation.

N/A

Based on the provided information, here are some innovations that can be used to improve access to maternal health:

1. Capacity building: Similar to the capacity building efforts for cancer prevention and early detection, training programs can be developed to educate healthcare workers on maternal health issues, including prenatal care, childbirth, and postnatal care. This can help improve the knowledge and skills of healthcare providers in addressing maternal health needs.

2. Development of educational materials: Just like the cancer information materials developed for health workers and communities, specific educational materials can be created for maternal health. These materials can provide information on pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, and postpartum care, and can be distributed to healthcare facilities and communities to improve awareness and understanding of maternal health.

3. Integration of maternal health into primary healthcare: Similar to the integration of cancer prevention and early detection into primary healthcare, efforts can be made to integrate maternal health services into existing primary healthcare facilities. This can involve training healthcare workers on providing comprehensive maternal health services, ensuring the availability of necessary equipment and supplies, and establishing referral systems for high-risk pregnancies.

4. Use of technology: Technology can be leveraged to improve access to maternal health services. This can include the use of telemedicine for remote consultations, mobile applications for tracking pregnancy progress and receiving health information, and SMS reminders for prenatal and postnatal appointments.

5. Community engagement: Engaging communities in maternal health initiatives can help increase awareness and promote positive health-seeking behaviors. This can involve community education sessions, involvement of community health workers in maternal health programs, and the establishment of support groups for pregnant women and new mothers.

These innovations can contribute to improving access to maternal health services, increasing awareness and knowledge, and ultimately reducing maternal mortality and morbidity rates.
AI Innovations Description
The recommendation to improve access to maternal health in Uganda is to implement capacity building efforts similar to those described in the study. This would involve conducting consultative meetings with stakeholders, developing and distributing educational materials on maternal health, and providing training to primary healthcare workers.

Specifically, the capacity building activities should focus on integrating maternal health prevention and early detection strategies into existing primary healthcare facilities. This could include raising awareness about maternal health risks and symptoms, promoting prenatal and postnatal care, and providing training on screening and early diagnosis techniques for common maternal health issues.

The training should target district primary healthcare teams, including assistant district health officers, medical officers or clinical officers, nursing officers, and health educators. These individuals should be selected based on their willingness to participate and their roles in maternal health care.

During the training, interactive teaching methods such as lectures, demonstrations, role plays, and group discussions should be used to enhance learning. Pre- and post-tests can be used to assess learning progress.

After the training, a follow-up should be conducted in the districts to evaluate the implementation of the recommended actions. This can help identify any challenges or areas for improvement.

By implementing these capacity building efforts, it is expected that access to maternal health services will be improved in Uganda, leading to better maternal health outcomes for women in the country.
AI Innovations Methodology
Based on the provided description, here are some potential recommendations for improving access to maternal health:

1. Strengthening Primary Healthcare Facilities: Enhance the capacity of primary healthcare facilities to provide comprehensive maternal health services, including prenatal care, skilled birth attendance, and postnatal care. This can be achieved by training healthcare workers, improving infrastructure and equipment, and ensuring the availability of essential medicines and supplies.

2. Community-Based Interventions: Implement community-based interventions to increase awareness and knowledge about maternal health, promote healthy behaviors during pregnancy, and encourage early utilization of maternal health services. This can involve community health workers conducting home visits, organizing health education sessions, and engaging with local leaders and community members.

3. Mobile Health (mHealth) Solutions: Utilize mobile health technologies to improve access to maternal health information and services. This can include mobile apps for pregnant women to track their health and receive personalized advice, SMS reminders for antenatal and postnatal care appointments, and telemedicine consultations for remote areas.

4. Transportation Support: Address transportation barriers by providing transportation vouchers or subsidies for pregnant women to access healthcare facilities. This can involve partnerships with local transportation providers or the use of community ambulances to ensure timely and safe transportation for pregnant women in need of emergency care.

To simulate the impact of these recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a methodology could include the following steps:

1. Data Collection: Gather baseline data on the current status of maternal health access, including indicators such as the percentage of pregnant women receiving prenatal care, skilled birth attendance rates, and postnatal care utilization. This can be done through surveys, health facility records, and existing data sources.

2. Modeling and Simulation: Use mathematical modeling techniques to simulate the potential impact of the recommended interventions on maternal health access. This can involve creating a simulation model that incorporates factors such as population demographics, healthcare facility capacity, and the effectiveness of the interventions.

3. Parameter Estimation: Estimate the parameters of the simulation model based on available data and evidence from similar interventions implemented in other settings. This can involve conducting literature reviews, consulting with experts, and analyzing relevant data sources.

4. Scenario Analysis: Explore different scenarios by varying the parameters of the simulation model to assess the potential impact of different combinations of interventions. This can help identify the most effective and cost-efficient strategies for improving access to maternal health.

5. Sensitivity Analysis: Conduct sensitivity analysis to assess the robustness of the simulation results to changes in key parameters. This can help identify the factors that have the greatest influence on the outcomes and inform decision-making.

6. Evaluation and Validation: Validate the simulation model by comparing the simulated results with real-world data from pilot interventions or similar programs. This can help assess the accuracy and reliability of the model and ensure that it provides meaningful insights for decision-makers.

By following these steps, policymakers and healthcare providers can gain valuable insights into the potential impact of different interventions on improving access to maternal health and make informed decisions about resource allocation and program implementation.

Share this:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email
Chat Icon DIMA AI Care
×