Intersections of girl child marriage and family planning beliefs and use: qualitative findings from Ethiopia and India

listen audio

Study Justification:
– Child marriage and early first birth are significant social, economic, and health concerns in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia.
– This study aims to explore the barriers and facilitators to family planning among women and girls who have experienced child marriage or have been able to avoid it.
– The findings will provide insights into the factors that influence family planning decisions in these contexts and inform the development of effective interventions.
Highlights:
– The study conducted in-depth interviews with 128 women and girls who were married as minors or who avoided child marriage, as well as their marital decision-makers.
– Barriers to family planning identified include social norms, such as child marriage and pressure to have children, and lack of information.
– Benefits of family planning include delayed first birth, increased birth spacing, improved maternal and child health, and girls’ educational attainment.
– Family planning use was associated with delayed pregnancy and increased educational attainment, particularly in Ethiopia.
– Ethiopia’s school-based program was found to be more effective in improving access to health workers and contraception compared to India’s community-based program.
– The study highlights the vulnerability of young wives in terms of reproductive control and emphasizes the need for multi-sector approaches to improve family planning among young wives.
Recommendations:
– Implement multi-sector approaches that involve communities, schools, and community health workers to improve family planning among young wives.
– Strengthen child marriage prevention programs as important sources of family planning information.
– Increase access to information about family planning and address social norms that perpetuate child marriage and pressure to have children.
– Enhance educational opportunities for girls to delay marriage and prioritize their reproductive health.
Key Role Players:
– Government agencies responsible for health, education, and women’s rights.
– Non-governmental organizations working on child marriage prevention and family planning.
– Community leaders and religious leaders.
– Health workers and educators.
– Researchers and academics.
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Development and implementation of multi-sector programs.
– Training and capacity building for health workers and educators.
– Awareness campaigns and information dissemination.
– Monitoring and evaluation of program effectiveness.
– Research and data collection.
– Collaboration and coordination between different stakeholders.
– Advocacy and policy development.

Child marriage and subsequent early first birth is a considerable social, economic and health concern, and a pervasive practice in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia. This study explores barriers and facilitators to family planning among women and girls, and their marital decision-makers subsequent to receipt of child marriage prevention programmes in Ethiopia and India. In-depth interviews with 128 women and girls who were married as minors or who cancelled or postponed marriage as minors and their marital decision-makers were analysed using content analysis. Respondents identified social norms, including child marriage and pressure to have children, and lack of information as barriers to family planning. Benefits included delayed first birth and increased birth spacing, improved maternal and child health and girls’ educational attainment. Respondents associated family planning use with delayed pregnancy and increased educational attainment, particularly in Ethiopia. Child marriage prevention programmes were identified as important sources of family planning information. Ethiopia’s school-based programme strengthened access to health workers and contraception more so than India’s community-based programme. Findings highlight young wives’ vulnerability with regard to reproductive control, and support the need for multi-sector approaches across communities, schools and community health workers to improve family planning among young wives.

N/A

Based on the description provided, here are some potential innovations that could be recommended to improve access to maternal health:

1. Strengthening community-based programs: Based on the findings, it is suggested to enhance community-based programs in India to improve access to family planning information and services. This could involve increasing the presence of community health workers who can provide education, counseling, and access to contraception.

2. School-based programs: The study highlights the effectiveness of Ethiopia’s school-based program in improving access to health workers and contraception. Therefore, implementing similar school-based programs in other regions could be beneficial. These programs can provide comprehensive sexual and reproductive health education, including information on family planning, to young girls.

3. Multi-sector approaches: The study emphasizes the need for multi-sector approaches to address the barriers to family planning among young wives. This could involve collaboration between government agencies, NGOs, schools, and community health workers to create a comprehensive support system that addresses social norms, provides education, and ensures access to contraception.

4. Empowering women and girls: To improve access to maternal health, it is crucial to empower women and girls by providing them with information, resources, and decision-making power regarding their reproductive health. This can be achieved through targeted interventions that promote gender equality, education, and awareness about family planning options.

5. Addressing social norms: The study identifies social norms, including child marriage and pressure to have children, as barriers to family planning. Therefore, interventions should focus on challenging and changing these norms through community engagement, awareness campaigns, and advocacy efforts.

6. Improving information dissemination: Lack of information was identified as a barrier to family planning. Therefore, innovative approaches such as mobile health (mHealth) applications, telemedicine, and community radio programs can be utilized to disseminate accurate and reliable information about family planning methods, benefits, and services.

These recommendations aim to address the specific barriers and facilitators identified in the study and provide potential innovations to improve access to maternal health in the context of child marriage and family planning beliefs.
AI Innovations Description
Based on the study’s findings, the following recommendation can be developed into an innovation to improve access to maternal health:

1. Multi-sector approach: Implement a comprehensive approach that involves multiple sectors, including communities, schools, and community health workers. This approach should aim to address the barriers and facilitators to family planning among young wives and their marital decision-makers.

2. Child marriage prevention programs: Strengthen child marriage prevention programs to not only focus on preventing early marriages but also provide information and resources on family planning. These programs can serve as important sources of family planning information for young wives.

3. Education and awareness: Increase education and awareness about the benefits of family planning, including delayed first birth, increased birth spacing, improved maternal and child health, and girls’ educational attainment. Emphasize the positive outcomes associated with family planning use, particularly in terms of delayed pregnancy and increased educational opportunities.

4. Access to health workers and contraception: Improve access to health workers and contraception, especially in school-based settings. Learn from the success of Ethiopia’s school-based program, which strengthened access to health workers and contraception more effectively than India’s community-based program.

5. Address social norms: Address social norms that perpetuate child marriage and pressure young wives to have children. Challenge these norms by promoting the benefits of family planning and empowering young wives to make informed decisions about their reproductive health.

By implementing these recommendations, it is possible to develop innovative strategies that can improve access to maternal health for young wives and contribute to reducing the social, economic, and health concerns associated with child marriage and early first births.
AI Innovations Methodology
To improve access to maternal health, here are some potential recommendations:

1. Strengthening education and awareness: Implement comprehensive sex education programs that provide information on family planning, reproductive health, and the consequences of child marriage. This can be done through schools, community centers, and outreach programs.

2. Empowering women and girls: Promote gender equality and empower women and girls to make informed decisions about their reproductive health. This can be achieved through initiatives that provide economic opportunities, support girls’ education, and challenge harmful social norms.

3. Increasing availability of family planning services: Ensure that affordable and accessible family planning services, including contraceptives, are readily available in both rural and urban areas. This can be done by improving the distribution and supply chain, training healthcare providers, and reducing financial barriers.

4. Engaging community leaders and stakeholders: Involve community leaders, religious leaders, and other stakeholders in promoting family planning and addressing the issue of child marriage. This can help change social norms and create a supportive environment for women and girls.

To simulate the impact of these recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a methodology could include the following steps:

1. Data collection: Gather baseline data on the current state of maternal health, child marriage rates, family planning use, and other relevant indicators in the target areas (Ethiopia and India).

2. Modeling: Use mathematical modeling techniques to simulate the potential impact of the recommendations. This could involve creating a simulation model that incorporates factors such as population demographics, healthcare infrastructure, access to education, and social norms.

3. Scenario analysis: Develop different scenarios based on the recommendations mentioned above. For example, one scenario could simulate the impact of increasing access to family planning services, while another scenario could explore the effects of empowering women and girls through education and economic opportunities.

4. Data analysis: Analyze the simulation results to assess the potential impact of each scenario on improving access to maternal health. This could include measuring changes in maternal mortality rates, contraceptive prevalence, age at first birth, and educational attainment.

5. Policy recommendations: Based on the simulation results, provide policymakers with evidence-based recommendations on which interventions are likely to have the greatest impact on improving access to maternal health. This can help guide the allocation of resources and the development of targeted interventions.

It’s important to note that the methodology described here is a general framework and may need to be adapted based on the specific context and available data in Ethiopia and India.

Share this:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email