The Integration of vertical and horizontal programmes for health systems strengthening in Malawi: a case study

listen audio

Study Justification:
– The health system in Malawi faces challenges due to funding allocation influenced by donor priorities.
– Mandated routine elements of service delivery may not be fully offered due to lack of resources or programmatic priority.
– Integrating vertical programs into existing horizontal services has the potential to improve access and quality of service delivery for Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent Health (RMNCAH) in Malawi.
Study Highlights:
– Identified and tabulated the main vertical funding streams currently available in Malawi.
– Identified intersections between vertical programs and existing horizontal health sector programs to strengthen RMNCAH.
– Explored how each vertical programmatic component can be adapted and integrated to support broader system strengthening within RMNCAH.
– Focused on areas such as drug and commodity procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading, health service activity data systems, human resources for RMNCAH provision, and community engagement and mobilization.
Recommendations:
– Integrate horizontal and existing vertical programs to improve RMNCAH in Malawi.
– Adapt and integrate vertical programmatic components to support broader system strengthening within RMNCAH.
– Focus on areas such as drug and commodity procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading, health service activity data systems, human resources for RMNCAH provision, and community engagement and mobilization.
Key Role Players:
– Ministry of Health
– Donor organizations
– Health facility managers
– Health service providers
– Community leaders and volunteers
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Drug and commodity procurement
– Supply chain logistics
– Health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading
– Health service activity data systems
– Human resources for RMNCAH provision
– Community engagement and mobilization

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is moderately strong. The authors provide a clear description of the challenge faced by the health system in Malawi and propose the integration of vertical and horizontal programs as a potential solution. They also identify and tabulate the main vertical funding streams available in Malawi and suggest how they can be adapted and integrated to strengthen RMNCAH. However, the abstract lacks specific data or results to support the effectiveness of this approach. To improve the evidence, the authors could include case studies or examples of successful integration efforts in other contexts, as well as potential outcomes or impact of the proposed integration on access and quality of service delivery.

A challenge for the health system in Malawi is that funding allocation is heavily influenced by donor priorities. As a result, mandated routine elements of service delivery may not be fully offered owing to lack of resources or programmatic priority. Integration of currently active ‘vertical’ programmes (those focused on a specific priority disease entity) into existing ‘horizontal’ services (meaning provision across the range of clinical and public health need) has potential to improve access and quality of service delivery for Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent Health (RMNCAH) in Malawi. We identified and tabulated the main vertical funding streams currently available in Malawi and identified where these could intersect with existing horizontal health sector programmes in order to strengthen RMNCAH. We have indicated how each of the main vertical programmatic components can be adapted and integrated to support broader system strengthening within RMNCAH focusing especially on drug and commodity procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading, health service activity data systems, human resources for ‘front line’ RMNCAH provision, as well as community engagement and mobilization. By circumventing the various limitations of vertical programmes in the delivery of health services in the country, they would complement existing funding streams rather than operating in a vacuum as independent activities. We therefore recommend the integration of horizontal and existing vertical programmes in order to improve RMNCAH in Malawi.

N/A

The publication titled “The Integration of vertical and horizontal programmes for health systems strengthening in Malawi: a case study” recommends integrating existing “vertical” programs with “horizontal” services to improve access and quality of Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent Health (RMNCAH) services in Malawi. The publication suggests identifying and tabulating the main vertical funding streams in Malawi and finding opportunities for them to intersect with existing horizontal health sector programs. This integration can address various aspects such as drug procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility maintenance, data systems, human resources, and community engagement. By integrating vertical and horizontal programs, the limitations of vertical programs can be overcome, and they can complement existing funding streams to improve RMNCAH services in Malawi.
AI Innovations Description
The recommendation proposed in the publication titled “The Integration of vertical and horizontal programmes for health systems strengthening in Malawi: a case study” is to integrate existing “vertical” programs, which focus on specific priority diseases, with “horizontal” services, which provide a range of clinical and public health services. This integration aims to improve access and quality of service delivery for Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent Health (RMNCAH) in Malawi.

The publication suggests identifying and tabulating the main vertical funding streams currently available in Malawi and finding opportunities for them to intersect with existing horizontal health sector programs. This integration can strengthen RMNCAH by addressing various aspects such as drug and commodity procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading, health service activity data systems, human resources for RMNCAH provision, as well as community engagement and mobilization.

By integrating vertical and horizontal programs, the limitations of vertical programs in delivering health services can be circumvented, and they can complement existing funding streams rather than operating independently. This recommendation aims to improve the overall delivery of RMNCAH services in Malawi.

Publication details:
Title: The Integration of vertical and horizontal programmes for health systems strengthening in Malawi: a case study
Publication: Malawi Medical Journal, Volume 34, No. 3, Year 2022
AI Innovations Methodology
To simulate the impact of the recommendations proposed in the publication on improving access to maternal health, a possible methodology could involve the following steps:

1. Data collection: Gather relevant data on the current state of maternal health services in Malawi, including indicators such as maternal mortality rates, access to antenatal care, skilled birth attendance, and postnatal care.

2. Identify key vertical programs: Identify the main vertical programs currently active in Malawi that focus on specific priority diseases related to reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health (RMNCAH). This can be done by reviewing existing program documentation and consulting with relevant stakeholders.

3. Assess program components: Analyze the programmatic components of each identified vertical program, including drug and commodity procurement, supply chain logistics, health facility and equipment maintenance/upgrading, health service activity data systems, human resources for RMNCAH provision, and community engagement and mobilization.

4. Identify opportunities for integration: Identify areas where the vertical programs can intersect with existing horizontal health sector programs to strengthen RMNCAH. This can be done by mapping the program components of the vertical programs onto the corresponding components of the horizontal programs.

5. Develop integration strategies: Develop strategies for adapting and integrating the programmatic components of the vertical programs into the existing horizontal programs. This may involve aligning procurement processes, integrating data systems, coordinating human resources, and enhancing community engagement.

6. Simulate impact: Use modeling techniques or simulation tools to estimate the potential impact of the integration strategies on improving access to maternal health services. This could include projecting changes in maternal mortality rates, increased coverage of antenatal and postnatal care, and improved availability of essential drugs and commodities.

7. Evaluate results: Assess the simulated impact and evaluate the effectiveness of the integration strategies in improving access to maternal health services. This can be done by comparing the simulated outcomes with the baseline data collected in step 1.

8. Refine recommendations: Based on the evaluation results, refine the recommendations for integrating vertical and horizontal programs to further enhance the delivery of RMNCAH services in Malawi. This may involve adjusting integration strategies, identifying additional areas for improvement, or addressing any challenges or limitations identified during the evaluation.

By following this methodology, policymakers and stakeholders can gain insights into the potential benefits of integrating vertical and horizontal programs for improving access to maternal health services in Malawi and make informed decisions on implementing these recommendations.

Share this:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email