Ghana’s community-based primary health care: Why women and children are ‘disadvantaged’ by its implementation

listen audio

Study Justification:
This study aims to analyze the implementation of community-based primary health care (PHC) programs in Ghana and understand why women and children in low- and middle-income settings are still disadvantaged in accessing appropriate care. The study addresses a gap in policy analysis by exploring the actions of frontline providers (FLP) and their interaction with health system factors that contribute to the disadvantage faced by women and children in accessing and using health services.
Highlights:
– The study was conducted in 4 communities in rural and urban districts of the Upper West region of Ghana.
– Data were collected through focus group discussions, in-depth interviews with clients, district health managers, and FLP, as well as observations.
– Findings revealed that FLP lateness and absenteeism affected care seeking for children, and their discretionary power in determining who receives care had negative consequences.
– Families faced financial hardships seeking alternative care for children, leading them to manage symptoms with care provided in non-traditional spaces.
– Weak implementation structures embedded in the district health systems contributed to FLP adverse behaviors.
– Lack of basic obstetric facilities prompted FLP to conduct deliveries using improvised methods, increasing the risk of unassisted home deliveries.
– Perceived poor conditions of service weakened FLP commitment to quality maternal and child care delivery.
Recommendations:
– Implement strategies to induce behavior change in FLP to improve their punctuality, attendance, and decision-making regarding care provision.
– Strengthen district administrative structures to ensure effective implementation of community-based PHC programs.
– Improve the supply chain and logistics system to address gaps in maternal and child care delivery in Community-based Health Planning and Services (CHPS) facilities.
Key Role Players:
– Frontline providers (FLP)
– District health managers
– Community informants
– Clients
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Training programs for FLP to improve their skills and behavior
– Infrastructure development for CHPS facilities, including the provision of basic obstetric facilities
– Strengthening administrative structures through capacity building and recruitment
– Investment in the supply chain and logistics system for efficient delivery of maternal and child care services

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is based on a qualitative study conducted in 4 communities. The study used multiple data collection methods and analysis techniques. However, the evidence could be strengthened by including a larger sample size and conducting a quantitative study to provide more generalizable results. Additionally, the abstract could provide more specific details about the study design, such as the selection criteria for the communities and participants. To improve the evidence, future research could consider expanding the study to include a wider range of communities and districts, as well as incorporating quantitative measures to assess the impact of the interventions.

Policy analysis on why women and children in low- and middle-income settings are still disadvantaged by access to appropriate care despite Primary Health Care (PHC) programmes implementation is limited. Drawing on the street-level bureaucracy theory, we explored how and why frontline providers (FLP) actions on their own and in interaction with health system factors shape Ghana’s community-based PHC implementation to the disadvantage of women and children accessing and using health services. This was a qualitative study conducted in 4 communities drawn from rural and urban districts of the Upper West region. Data were collected from 8 focus group discussions with community informants, 73 in-depth interviews with clients, 13 in-depth interviews with district health managers and FLP, and observations. Data were recorded, transcribed and coded deductively and inductively for themes with the aid of Nvivo 11 software. Findings showed that apart from FLP frequent lateness to, and absenteeism from work, that affected care seeking for children, their exercise of discretionary power in determining children who deserve care over others had ripple effects: families experienced financial hardships in seeking alternative care for children, and avoided that by managing symptoms with care provided in non-traditional spaces. FLP adverse behaviours were driven by weak implementation structures embedded in the district health systems. Basic obstetric facilities such as labour room, infusion stand, and beds for deliveries, detention and palpation were lacking prompting FLP to cope by conducting deliveries using a patchwork of improvised delivery methods which worked out to encourage unassisted home deliveries. Perceived poor conditions of service weakened FLP commitment to quality maternal and child care delivery. Findings suggest the need for strategies to induce behaviour change in FLP, strengthen district administrative structures, and improve on the supply chain and logistics system to address gaps in CHPS maternal and child care delivery.

N/A

The publication “Ghana’s community-based primary health care: Why women and children are ‘disadvantaged’ by its implementation” suggests several recommendations to improve access to maternal health. These recommendations can be developed into innovations as follows:

1. Behavior Change Intervention for Frontline Providers (FLP): Develop and implement a comprehensive behavior change intervention targeting FLP to address issues such as frequent lateness, absenteeism, and exercise of discretionary power. This innovation could involve training programs, workshops, and mentoring sessions to improve FLP commitment to quality maternal and child care delivery.

2. Strengthen District Administrative Structures: Enhance the capacity and effectiveness of district administrative structures responsible for overseeing the implementation of community-based primary health care programs. This innovation could include training programs for district health managers, resource allocation for improved supervision and support, and regular monitoring and evaluation to ensure accountability and effectiveness.

3. Improve Supply Chain and Logistics System: Address gaps in the supply chain and logistics system to ensure the availability of basic obstetric facilities and essential medical supplies. This innovation could involve establishing a robust supply chain management system, improving infrastructure for obstetric facilities, and ensuring a consistent supply of necessary equipment and medications.

By implementing these innovations, it is expected that access to maternal health services will be improved, reducing the disadvantages faced by women and children in low- and middle-income settings. These innovations aim to address the underlying issues identified in the research findings and create a more supportive and effective healthcare system for maternal health.
AI Innovations Description
Based on the research findings described in the publication “Ghana’s community-based primary health care: Why women and children are ‘disadvantaged’ by its implementation,” the following recommendation can be developed into an innovation to improve access to maternal health:

1. Behavior Change Intervention for Frontline Providers (FLP): Develop and implement a comprehensive behavior change intervention targeting FLP to address issues such as frequent lateness, absenteeism, and exercise of discretionary power. This intervention should focus on improving their commitment to quality maternal and child care delivery.

2. Strengthen District Administrative Structures: Enhance the capacity and effectiveness of district administrative structures responsible for overseeing the implementation of community-based primary health care programs. This can be achieved through training, resource allocation, and regular monitoring and evaluation.

3. Improve Supply Chain and Logistics System: Address gaps in the supply chain and logistics system to ensure the availability of basic obstetric facilities and essential medical supplies. This includes providing labor rooms, infusion stands, beds for deliveries, detention, and palpation. Strengthening the supply chain will help FLP deliver appropriate care and reduce the need for improvised delivery methods.

By implementing these recommendations, it is expected that access to maternal health services will be improved, reducing the disadvantages faced by women and children in low- and middle-income settings.
AI Innovations Methodology
To simulate the impact of the main recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a mixed-methods approach could be employed. Here is a brief methodology:

1. Quantitative Data Collection:
– Conduct a survey among frontline providers (FLP) to assess their current behaviors, attitudes, and commitment to maternal and child care delivery.
– Collect data on the availability of basic obstetric facilities and essential medical supplies through facility assessments and inventory checks.
– Gather information on the frequency of lateness, absenteeism, and exercise of discretionary power among FLP through self-reporting or administrative records.

2. Qualitative Data Collection:
– Conduct focus group discussions with community informants to understand their perspectives on the challenges faced in accessing maternal health services.
– Conduct in-depth interviews with clients to gather their experiences and perceptions of the quality of care received.
– Interview district health managers and FLP to gain insights into the existing administrative structures and supply chain logistics.

3. Data Analysis:
– Analyze the quantitative data using statistical methods to determine the baseline levels of FLP behaviors, availability of obstetric facilities, and medical supplies.
– Analyze the qualitative data using thematic analysis to identify key themes related to access to maternal health services and the impact of FLP behaviors and health system factors.

4. Simulation:
– Develop a simulation model that incorporates the baseline data and the proposed interventions.
– Use the simulation model to project the potential impact of the behavior change intervention for FLP, strengthening district administrative structures, and improving the supply chain and logistics system on access to maternal health services.
– Adjust the model parameters based on the findings from the data analysis and expert input.

5. Evaluation:
– Compare the simulated outcomes with the baseline data to assess the potential improvements in access to maternal health services.
– Conduct sensitivity analyses to test the robustness of the simulation results.
– Validate the simulation results by comparing them with real-world data, if available.

By following this methodology, researchers can simulate the potential impact of the recommendations on improving access to maternal health services in Ghana’s community-based primary health care system.

Share this:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email
Chat Icon DIMA AI Care
×