Management of post abortion complications in Botswana -The need for a standardized approach

listen audio

Study Justification:
– Post-abortion complications are a significant cause of maternal death in Botswana, ranking third after hemorrhage and hypertension.
– Abortion is not legalized in Botswana, leading to potential risks and complications for women seeking abortion services.
– The study aimed to assess the management of post-abortion complications in Botswana to identify areas for improvement and standardization.
Study Highlights:
– A retrospective study was conducted at four hospitals in Botswana in 2014.
– Data was collected from patients’ medical records, including socio-demographic information, patient management, and outcomes.
– The study found evidence of delayed patient care and prolonged hospital stays.
– Metallic curette was the primary method used for uterine evacuation across all facilities.
– Pain management and antibiotics use were not standardized.
– The study recommends the development of a protocol to standardize post-abortion care.
Recommendations for Lay Reader and Policy Maker:
– Develop a standardized protocol for post-abortion care to ensure timely and appropriate treatment for women experiencing complications.
– Improve pain management and ensure the use of standardized antibiotics to prevent infections.
– Consider alternative methods for uterine evacuation, such as vacuum aspiration, to reduce the reliance on metallic curettage.
– Increase awareness and access to post-abortion family planning services to prevent future unintended pregnancies.
Key Role Players:
– Ministry of Health: Responsible for developing and implementing the standardized protocol for post-abortion care.
– Healthcare providers: Involved in the implementation of the protocol and providing appropriate treatment to patients.
– Clinicians and midwives: Responsible for collecting and analyzing data related to post-abortion complications.
– Ethical committees and institutional review boards: Provide oversight and ensure ethical considerations are met during the study.
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Training and capacity building for healthcare providers on the standardized protocol for post-abortion care.
– Procurement of necessary medical equipment and supplies for alternative methods of uterine evacuation.
– Implementation of a comprehensive pain management program, including the availability of analgesics and anesthetics.
– Development and dissemination of educational materials on post-abortion family planning.
– Monitoring and evaluation activities to assess the effectiveness of the standardized protocol and identify areas for improvement.

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is moderately strong. The study conducted a retrospective analysis of 619 patients’ medical records, which provides a good sample size. The use of descriptive statistics and chi-square test for data analysis adds to the strength of the study. However, the abstract does not mention the specific outcomes or results of the study, making it difficult to fully assess the strength of the evidence. To improve the evidence, the abstract should include a summary of the key findings and their implications for post-abortion care in Botswana.

Background Post abortion complications are the third leading cause of maternal death after hemorrhage and hypertension in Botswana where abortion is not legalized. This study aimed at assessing the management of post abortion complications in Botswana. Methods A retrospective study was conducted at four hospitals in Botswana in 2014. Socio-demo-graphic, patient management and outcomes data were extracted from patients’ medical records. Descriptive statistics and chi-square test were used to analyze and present the data. Result A total of 619 patients’ medical records were reviewed. The duration of hospital stay prior to uterine evacuation ranged from less than an hour to 480 hours. All the patients received either prophylactic or therapeutic antibiotics. Use of parenteral antibiotics was significantly associated with severity of abortion, second trimester abortion, use of blood products and the interval between management’s decision and uterine evacuation. Uterine evacuation for retained products of conception was achieved by metallic curettage among 516 (83.4%) patients and by vacuum aspiration in 18 (2.9%). At all the study sites, Misoprostol or Oxytocin were used concurrently with surgical evacuation of the uterus. None use of analgesics or anesthetics in the four hospitals ranged between 12.4% to 28.8%. Conclusion There is evidence of delayed patient care and prolonged hospital stay. Metallic curette was the primary method used for uterine evacuation across all the facilities. Pain management and antibiotics use was not standardized. A protocol has to be developed with the aim of standardizing post abortion care.

Botswana, a middle income country in Southern Africa, has a total population of 2.02 million inhabitants with a female to male ratio of 1.05. Half of this female population is in the reproductive age of 15–49 years with a total fertility rate of 2.9 Children per woman [14, 15]. There are 28 public hospitals: 3 referral, 10 district and 15 primary hospitals in the country. A 2012 report of referral Hospitals in Botswana revealed that abortion complications accounted for more than 60–65% of admissions to Gynecology wards (Unpublished report). A retrospective, institution based, cross sectional study was conducted at four selected hospitals in Botswana. Data was collected from patients`records admitted for the management of post-abortion complications between January and August 2014. The term post-abortion complication was used in our study for all patients admitted with pregnancy loss before 24 weeks regardless of the cause. Data was collected from four hospitals, selected using convenience sampling in the different districts. These included two referral: Princes Marina Hospital (PMH) and Nyangabgwe Referral Hospital (NRH); and two district hospitals: Mahalapye and Maun hospitals located in the southern, central and northern parts of the country. All patients’ records were reviewed for individual and clinical information, including their management outcome for post-abortion complications. Data was collected by trained clinicians and midwives who were members of investigating team. The data collected included patient socio-demographic variables, abortion complications, patient management and treatment outcome. Information on patient management and outcomes such as: diagnosis, intervention interval and standard of care, use of blood products, operative interventions, means of uterine evacuation, administration of antibiotics, counseling, post abortion family planning and any abortion related maternal death were collected. Completeness and accuracy of the data were checked. Data was collected at the respective hospitals using a structured data extraction sheet. All records of threatened abortion, ectopic pregnancy, molar pregnancy and other abnormal non pregnancy related uterine bleeding were excluded from the study. The patients were grouped into different levels of severity as follows: SPSS 22 software was used for data entry, cleaning and analysis. Frequencies, percentage, and chi-square test were utilized in the presentation of the findings. A p-value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Ethical clearance was obtained from the institutional review boards of the University of Botswana, Ministry of Health and ethical committees of the four study hospitals. As the study was retrospective, patients had already been managed as per the hospital management protocol and hence the data extraction did not have any effect on the patient care. Since all the patients were not in the hospital at the time of data collection, informed consent was waived by the institutional review boards to access patient`s records.

Based on the information provided, here are some potential innovations that could improve access to maternal health in Botswana:

1. Standardized Protocol for Post-Abortion Care: Develop a standardized protocol for the management of post-abortion complications in Botswana. This protocol should outline the recommended procedures, medications, and interventions for healthcare providers to follow, ensuring consistent and effective care for patients.

2. Improved Pain Management: Implement standardized guidelines for the use of analgesics and anesthetics during post-abortion care. This will help alleviate pain and discomfort for patients undergoing uterine evacuation procedures.

3. Streamlined Patient Care: Address the issue of delayed patient care and prolonged hospital stays by implementing strategies to streamline the management of post-abortion complications. This could include improving communication and coordination between healthcare providers, ensuring timely decision-making, and reducing unnecessary delays in uterine evacuation.

4. Increased Access to Non-Surgical Methods: Explore the use of non-surgical methods, such as medication (Misoprostol) or vacuum aspiration, for uterine evacuation in post-abortion care. This could provide a less invasive and more accessible option for patients, especially in areas where surgical facilities may be limited.

5. Antibiotic Standardization: Develop guidelines for the standardized use of antibiotics in post-abortion care. This will help ensure appropriate and consistent antibiotic administration, taking into account factors such as severity of abortion, gestational age, and use of blood products.

6. Post-Abortion Family Planning: Integrate comprehensive family planning counseling and services into post-abortion care. This will help address the contraceptive needs of women who have experienced pregnancy loss and reduce the risk of future unintended pregnancies.

These innovations aim to improve the quality and accessibility of post-abortion care in Botswana, ultimately reducing maternal morbidity and mortality associated with abortion complications.
AI Innovations Description
Based on the information provided, a recommendation to improve access to maternal health in Botswana would be to develop a standardized approach for the management of post-abortion complications. This recommendation is based on the findings of the study, which highlighted several areas for improvement.

1. Develop a standardized protocol: A protocol should be developed that outlines the standardized approach for the management of post-abortion complications. This protocol should include guidelines for the duration of hospital stay prior to uterine evacuation, the use of prophylactic or therapeutic antibiotics, the method of uterine evacuation, and the concurrent use of medications such as Misoprostol or Oxytocin.

2. Improve timeliness of care: The study identified evidence of delayed patient care and prolonged hospital stay. To address this, efforts should be made to streamline the process of managing post-abortion complications, ensuring that patients receive timely and appropriate care.

3. Enhance pain management: The study found that none use of analgesics or anesthetics ranged between 12.4% to 28.8% in the four hospitals. It is important to prioritize pain management for patients undergoing uterine evacuation, ensuring that appropriate analgesics or anesthetics are administered to alleviate discomfort.

4. Standardize antibiotic use: The study revealed that the use of parenteral antibiotics was significantly associated with certain factors such as severity of abortion, second trimester abortion, use of blood products, and the interval between management’s decision and uterine evacuation. To ensure consistent and appropriate antibiotic use, guidelines should be established to guide healthcare providers in prescribing antibiotics for post-abortion complications.

5. Strengthen post-abortion family planning: The study did not specifically mention post-abortion family planning, but it is an important aspect of comprehensive post-abortion care. Efforts should be made to ensure that patients receive counseling and access to contraception following the management of post-abortion complications.

By implementing these recommendations, it is expected that access to maternal health in Botswana will be improved, leading to better outcomes for women experiencing post-abortion complications.
AI Innovations Methodology
In order to improve access to maternal health in Botswana, the following innovations and recommendations can be considered:

1. Standardized Approach: Develop a standardized approach for the management of post-abortion complications in Botswana. This would involve creating a protocol that outlines the best practices for patient care, including the use of antibiotics, pain management, and uterine evacuation methods.

2. Training and Education: Provide training and education to healthcare providers on the standardized approach for managing post-abortion complications. This would ensure that healthcare providers are equipped with the necessary knowledge and skills to provide quality care to patients.

3. Access to Medications: Ensure that healthcare facilities have a consistent supply of medications such as Misoprostol and Oxytocin, which are used for uterine evacuation. This would help to ensure that these medications are readily available when needed.

4. Improved Pain Management: Implement standardized pain management protocols to ensure that all patients receive appropriate analgesics or anesthetics during the management of post-abortion complications. This would help to alleviate pain and improve patient comfort.

5. Timely Care: Develop strategies to reduce delays in patient care and minimize the duration of hospital stay for patients with post-abortion complications. This could involve streamlining processes and improving coordination between healthcare providers.

To simulate the impact of these recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a methodology could be developed as follows:

1. Data Collection: Collect data on the current management of post-abortion complications in Botswana, including patient demographics, treatment protocols, outcomes, and duration of hospital stay. This could be done through a retrospective study, similar to the one described in the provided description.

2. Baseline Analysis: Analyze the collected data to establish a baseline for the current state of access to maternal health in Botswana. This would involve identifying key metrics such as the average duration of hospital stay, the percentage of patients receiving standardized care, and the use of pain management protocols.

3. Simulation Modeling: Develop a simulation model that incorporates the recommended innovations and recommendations. This model would simulate the impact of implementing these recommendations on access to maternal health in Botswana. It could consider factors such as the reduction in hospital stay duration, the increase in the percentage of patients receiving standardized care, and the improvement in pain management.

4. Sensitivity Analysis: Conduct sensitivity analysis to assess the robustness of the simulation model. This would involve testing the model under different scenarios and assumptions to evaluate its reliability and validity.

5. Impact Assessment: Evaluate the impact of the recommended innovations on access to maternal health in Botswana based on the simulation results. This would involve comparing the simulated outcomes with the baseline data to determine the extent of improvement achieved.

By following this methodology, policymakers and healthcare providers in Botswana can gain insights into the potential impact of implementing the recommended innovations on improving access to maternal health. This information can then be used to inform decision-making and guide the implementation of effective strategies.

Yabelana ngalokhu:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email