Maternal near-miss and death incidences – Frequencies, causes and the referral chain in Somaliland: A pilot study using the WHO near-miss approach

listen audio

Study Justification:
– The study aims to monitor the frequency and causes of maternal near-miss and deaths in Somaliland, a self-declared country with a population of 3.5 million.
– It also investigates the referral chain for women to access Skilled Birth Attendants (SBA).
– The study is important to understand the factors contributing to maternal near-miss and death incidences in Somaliland and to identify areas for improvement in maternal healthcare.
Study Highlights:
– The study identified 138 women with severe maternal complications: 120 maternal near-miss cases and 18 maternal deaths.
– Most near-miss cases (74.2%) occurred on arrival at the hospital, while a smaller proportion (25.8%) developed inside the hospital.
– Similarly, the majority of maternal deaths (77.8%) occurred on arrival at the hospital, with a smaller percentage (22.2%) occurring during hospitalization.
– Family referrals were the most common mode of referral for maternal near-miss cases, accounting for 66.7% of cases. Of the 18 maternal deaths, 15 were also family referrals.
– Reasons for bypassing Antenatal Care (ANC) included lack of confidence in the service provided, lack of financial resources, and lack of time to visit ANC.
– Reasons for late arrival to the referral hospital included lack of knowledge and transportation, as well as poor communication.
Recommendations for Lay Reader and Policy Maker:
– Increase the utilization of ANC to indirectly lower the number of near-miss and death events.
– Encourage collaboration between ANC staff and referral hospital staff to improve the referral chain and ensure timely access to skilled birth attendants.
– Implement a more comprehensive near-miss project to further investigate and address the factors contributing to maternal near-miss and death incidences.
Key Role Players:
– ANC staff
– Referral hospital staff
– Skilled Birth Attendants
– Community health workers
– Policy makers and government officials
– Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) working in maternal healthcare
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Training and capacity building for ANC staff and referral hospital staff
– Awareness campaigns to promote ANC utilization and educate communities on the importance of timely access to skilled birth attendants
– Improving transportation infrastructure and access to healthcare facilities
– Strengthening communication systems between ANC facilities and referral hospitals
– Research and data collection for a more comprehensive near-miss project

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is moderately strong. The study conducted a facility-based analysis of maternal near-miss and mortality cases over a 5-month period using the WHO near-miss tool. The study identified 138 women with severe maternal complications, including 120 near-miss cases and 18 maternal deaths. The study also investigated the reasons for bypassing the Antenatal Care facility and late arrival to the referral hospital through verbal autopsy. The findings suggest that there were more near-miss cases on arrival and more maternal deaths on arrival than during hospitalization. The most common mode of referral among near-miss events was family referrals, and the reasons for bypassing ANC and late arrival included lack of confidence in the service, lack of financial resources, lack of time, lack of knowledge and transportation, and poor communication. The conclusion highlights the importance of increasing ANC utilization to indirectly lower the number of near-miss and death events, and proposes collaboration between ANC staff and referral hospital staff, as well as a more comprehensive near-miss project. To improve the strength of the evidence, future studies could consider a larger sample size, longer study duration, and a multi-center approach to increase generalizability. Additionally, incorporating quantitative data alongside qualitative data could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the factors influencing maternal near-miss and death incidences in Somaliland.

Background Somaliland is a self-declared country with a population of 3.5 million. Most of its population reside in rural areas. The objective of this pilot near-miss study was to monitor the frequency and causes of maternal near-miss and deaths and the referral chain for women to access Skilled Birth Attendants (SBA). Method: A facility-based study of all maternal near-miss and mortality cases over 5 months using the WHO near-miss tool in a main referral hospital. Reasons for bypassing the Antenatal Care facility (ANC) and late arrival to the referral hospital were investigated through verbal autopsy. Results: One hundred and thirty-eight (138) women with severe maternal complications were identified: 120 maternal near-miss, 18 maternal deaths. There were more near-miss cases on arrival (74.2%) compared with events that developed inside the hospital (25.8%). Likewise, there were more maternal deaths (77.8%) on arrival than was the case during hospitalization (22.2%). The most common mode of referral among maternal near-miss events was family referrals (66.7%). Of 18 maternal deaths, 15 were family referrals. Reasons for bypassing ANC were as follows: lack of confidence in the service provided; lack of financial resources; and lack of time to visit ANC. Reasons for late arrival to the referral hospital were as follows: lack of knowledge and transportation; and poor communication. Conclusion and clinical implication: To increase the utilization of ANC might indirectly lower the number of near-miss and death events. Collaboration between ANC staff and referral hospital staff and a more comprehensive near-miss project are proposed.

Innovations to improve access to maternal health and increase the utilization of Antenatal Care (ANC) services include:

1. Addressing reasons for bypassing ANC: Implement strategies to build confidence in the services provided at ANC facilities, such as improving the quality of care and ensuring respectful and patient-centered care. Explore options for reducing financial barriers, such as providing subsidies or financial assistance programs. Develop initiatives to address time constraints, such as offering flexible scheduling or mobile ANC services.

2. Improving knowledge and transportation: Enhance community education and awareness programs to increase knowledge about the importance of ANC and the risks of late arrival to referral hospitals. Provide transportation options, such as ambulances or community transport services, to ensure timely access to care.

3. Enhancing communication: Strengthen communication channels between ANC facilities and referral hospitals to ensure smooth referrals and timely transfer of patients. This can include establishing clear protocols and guidelines for referral processes, implementing electronic medical records systems for seamless information sharing, and promoting effective communication between healthcare providers.

4. Collaboration between ANC staff and referral hospital staff: Foster collaboration and coordination between ANC staff and referral hospital staff to improve the continuity of care. This can involve joint training programs, regular meetings, and shared protocols to ensure a seamless transition for patients from ANC to referral hospitals.

5. Implementation of a comprehensive near-miss project: Develop a comprehensive near-miss project that focuses on identifying and addressing the underlying causes of maternal near-miss events. This can involve conducting regular audits and reviews of near-miss cases, implementing quality improvement initiatives, and strengthening the overall healthcare system to prevent future near-miss events.

These innovations aim to indirectly lower the number of maternal near-miss and death events by improving access to ANC services and addressing the barriers that prevent women from seeking timely care.
AI Innovations Description
The recommendation from the study to improve access to maternal health is to increase the utilization of Antenatal Care (ANC) services. This can be achieved by addressing the reasons for bypassing ANC, such as lack of confidence in the service provided, lack of financial resources, and lack of time to visit ANC. Additionally, improving knowledge and transportation, as well as enhancing communication, can help reduce late arrival to referral hospitals. The study suggests collaboration between ANC staff and referral hospital staff, as well as the implementation of a more comprehensive near-miss project. These measures aim to indirectly lower the number of maternal near-miss and death events.
AI Innovations Methodology
To simulate the impact of the main recommendations on improving access to maternal health, you could consider the following methodology:

1. Study Design: Conduct a prospective study in a representative sample of healthcare facilities in Somaliland, including both rural and urban areas.

2. Sample Selection: Randomly select a sufficient number of healthcare facilities to ensure a diverse representation of the population. Consider including a mix of primary healthcare centers, secondary hospitals, and tertiary referral hospitals.

3. Data Collection: Implement the WHO near-miss approach to identify and collect data on maternal near-miss and death cases over a specified period, such as 6 months or 1 year. Use the same near-miss tool used in the pilot study mentioned in the abstract.

4. Intervention Implementation: Implement the recommended interventions to improve access to maternal health services. This may include:

a. Addressing reasons for bypassing ANC: Develop strategies to improve confidence in ANC services, such as training healthcare providers and improving the quality of care. Implement financial support mechanisms to alleviate the financial burden of ANC visits. Explore options to increase the availability and accessibility of ANC services, such as extending clinic hours or providing mobile ANC services.

b. Improving knowledge and transportation: Conduct community awareness campaigns to educate women and their families about the importance of ANC and the risks of late arrival to referral hospitals. Enhance transportation options, such as providing subsidized transportation or improving road infrastructure.

c. Enhancing communication: Strengthen communication channels between ANC facilities, referral hospitals, and the community. This may involve implementing a system for timely and accurate referrals, establishing a helpline for pregnant women, or using mobile technology for appointment reminders and health education.

5. Data Analysis: Compare the frequency and causes of maternal near-miss and death cases before and after the implementation of the interventions. Analyze the data to assess the impact of the interventions on reducing the number of near-miss and death events.

6. Evaluation: Evaluate the effectiveness of the interventions by assessing the utilization of ANC services, the timeliness of referrals, and the overall satisfaction of pregnant women and healthcare providers. Conduct qualitative interviews or surveys to gather feedback on the implemented interventions.

7. Recommendations: Based on the findings, provide recommendations for scaling up the successful interventions and addressing any remaining barriers to improving access to maternal health services in Somaliland.

By following this methodology, you can simulate the impact of the recommended interventions on improving access to maternal health services and assess their effectiveness in reducing maternal near-miss and death events.

Yabelana ngalokhu:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email