Maternal Nutrition Education Provided by Midwives: A Qualitative Study in an Antenatal Clinic, Uganda

listen audio

Study Justification:
– Maternal nutrition during pregnancy is crucial for the health of both the mother and the baby.
– There is limited existing research on prenatal nutrition education in Uganda.
– The study aimed to address the high levels of uncertainty about the current education intervention and the limited resources available.
Highlights:
– The study examined the maternal nutrition education provided by midwives in an antenatal clinic in Uganda.
– In-depth interviews with midwives, structured observations of group education sessions, and one-on-one interactions between midwives and pregnant women were conducted.
– The study found that the content and presentation of maternal nutrition education were inadequate in scope and depth.
– The nutrition component was given minimal time during routine antenatal education sessions.
– The organization, mode of delivery, guidelines, resources, and service environment were deficient.
– Gaps in information, maternal nutrition education resources, infrastructure, and the health system were identified.
Recommendations:
– Provide appropriate in-service training, mentorship, and support for midwives to promote effective nutrition education.
– Improve infrastructure and resource provision in the antenatal clinic.
– Enhance the content and presentation of maternal nutrition education, including relevant topics such as appropriate weight gain during pregnancy, healthy habits, avoidance of substance abuse, and nutrition precautions in special circumstances.
Key Role Players:
– Midwives: They need to receive training, mentorship, and support to improve their nutrition education skills.
– Health authorities: They should provide resources and infrastructure to enhance the delivery of maternal nutrition education.
– Researchers and educators: They can contribute by developing appropriate training materials and guidelines for midwives.
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Training programs for midwives: This includes costs for curriculum development, trainers, training materials, and venue.
– Infrastructure improvement: Costs for renovating or expanding the antenatal clinic to accommodate the enhanced nutrition education.
– Educational resources: Budget for developing or procuring educational materials, such as pamphlets, posters, and audiovisual aids.
– Monitoring and evaluation: Allocate funds for assessing the effectiveness of the implemented recommendations and making necessary adjustments.

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 7 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is based on a qualitative study that used in-depth interviews and observations. While these methods provide valuable insights, they are subjective and may not be generalizable to a larger population. To improve the strength of the evidence, the study could have included a larger sample size and used quantitative measures to assess the effectiveness of the nutrition education. Additionally, the study could have included a control group to compare the outcomes of the intervention. These steps would provide more robust evidence for the effectiveness of the maternal nutrition education provided by midwives.

Maternal nutrition during pregnancy affects the health of the mother and baby. The objective of this paper is to describe the maternal nutrition education offered by midwives to women attending an antenatal clinic. The study also examined the resources, support, and the needs of the midwives in offering the nutrition education. Six in-depth interviews with the midwives, six direct structured observations of the group education, and 12 one-on-one interactions of midwife and pregnant women observations were completed. The interviews and field observation notes were typed and analyzed using the latent content analysis. The emerging themes were the maternal nutrition education and the education needs of the midwives. The content and presentation of maternal nutrition were inadequate in scope and depth. The maternal nutrition education was offered to only pregnant women attending the first antenatal care visit. The routine antenatal education session lasted 45 minutes to 1 hour, covering a variety of topics, but the nutritional component was allotted minimal time (5-15 minutes). The organization, mode of delivery, guidelines, resources, and service environment were extremely deficient. The relevance of appropriate weight gain during pregnancy, guidelines for healthy habits, avoidance of substance abuse, and nutrition precautions in special circumstances was missing in the nutrition presentation. Information, maternal nutrition education resources, infrastructure, and health system gaps were identified. There was an inefficient nutrition education offered to the pregnant women attending the antenatal clinic. As means of promoting effective nutrition education, appropriate in-service training, mentorship, and support for the midwives are needed, as well as infrastructural and resource provision.

A qualitative description approach was used based on the fact that there were high levels of uncertainty about the current education intervention and very little existing research on prenatal nutrition education in Uganda and at the same time limited resources to conduct the study [23]. The authors conducted six in-depth interviews with midwives who were involved in the direct care of the pregnant women at the ANC clinic. In-depth interviews are useful and appropriate for obtaining detailed information about a person’s thoughts and behaviors and often provide context to other data [24, 25]. In addition to the in-depth interviews, nonparticipant-structured observations of the nutrition education sessions during the routine ANC visits were conducted. The study included sessions conducted by the midwives, and this was the routine at the clinic. The observations included six group education sessions and twelve one-on-one interactions between the midwives and the pregnant women during the physical examination in the antenatal clinic. The study was conducted at an ANC clinic at a referral and teaching hospital in Uganda, and it is one of the busiest maternity units in the country. The ANC is offered to women of various ethnicities, socioeconomic classes, and religions. The clinic operated from Monday to Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm. It offered antenatal services including HIV counseling and testing, syphilis screening, health education that included nutrition education, screening, and examination, and referral services. The clinic was structured in two sections: a low-risk unit which was attended by women with good obstetrical history and a high-risk unit which was attended by women with poor obstetrical history. The clinic is predominantly staffed by midwives. At the time of the study, a total of 2,155 mothers had attended the antenatal clinic between January and March 2015, and the clinic had 29 midwives. In this study, the researchers looked out for any set of planned educational activities that involved teaching pregnant women about nutrition, providing educational materials that reinforced messages about healthy eating, taught nutritional skills essential for making a dietary change, and provided information on how to sustain the changed behavior. Group nutrition education included sessions where the midwife gave nutrition education to a group of pregnant women attending ANC. One-on-one interactions included an interface between a midwife and a pregnant woman with the intention of antenatal nutritional education [26]. The group education session observations were conducted in the morning hours of the antenatal clinic and the one-on-one interactions between women and the midwives continued throughout the day. The observations recorded information on the hospital education environment, organization of the sessions, conduct of the sessions, content of the nutrition class, evidence of planning and preparations for the education activities, documentation done by the midwife of the nutrition education activities, and the resources and the information education and communication (IEC) materials available at the clinic. The observations also included verbal behavior, body language, and objects or resources used during the nutrition education sessions. Midwives were observed during the formal teaching, during the informal teaching, and during the examination of the pregnant women. The researchers observed 6 group education sessions, and each of the midwives was observed at least twice during the informal education or examination sessions. The midwives conducted the education sessions in the local language, and however, the notes taken by the researcher were in English, and the researcher was well conversant with the local language and was able to take notes in English. The in-depth interviews were conducted in English. In-depth interviews and observation were conducted in January and February 2016. The researchers introduced themselves to the area managers and the in-charge nurse of the hospital antenatal care clinic. The purpose and procedure of the study were explained to the midwives in order to obtain permission for conducting the study in the clinic. After informed written consent was obtained, the researcher together with the midwife identified a time that was convenient for the in-depth interviews. An open-ended in-depth interview guide was used for data collection. This majorly focused on how the sessions are given, and the midwives’ challenge in giving the nutrition education. An appropriate time and setting for the interview were identified by the participant. The in-depth interview lasted between 30 and 60 minutes, the interviews were tape recorded, and the notes were also taken. A structured nonparticipant observer method allowed the researcher to look for specific behavior without interfering in the education sessions. The observer was visible and known to the study participants. Ethical review and approval were obtained from the Makerere School of Health Sciences research ethics committee (REF: 2015–026). The hospital gave the researchers administrative clearance to conduct the study. Informed written consent was obtained from the study participants. Confidentiality and privacy were maintained throughout the study period. The data collected were strictly for the purpose of this research, which were anonymized in the writing of this article. The audio data will be stored for 5 years after which they will be destroyed. The data files are stored in a computer with a password to allow only access by the researchers. Data from the in-depth interviews were transcribed verbatim. Notes were also taken during the structured observations. Microsoft word files for the interviews and observations notes were created. The files were password protected and were saved in a portable computer only accessible to the researchers. After the Microsoft word files were ready, all the researchers got copies and analysis began at an individual level. After an understanding of the data, the researchers met several times and a group data analysis was also done. The data were analyzed manually using latent content analysis (Hsieh and Shannon, 2005). The researchers used an interview or an observation as the unit of analysis for coding. This means that the data were not coded sentence-by-sentence or paragraph-by-paragraph but coded for meaning [27]. The transcripts were read and re-read by the researchers to develop coding categories, and a code book was developed to ensure consistent application of the final coding categories. The data were then coded independently by the researchers. The codes were later reviewed by the researchers to ensure agreement and consistency of meaning in situations where differences arose. The agreed upon codes were synthesized and grouped into exhaustive subcategories which were then merged into categories/themes. These represented the most common issues that emerged in the interviews and observations [5].

Based on the information provided, here are some potential innovations that could improve access to maternal health:

1. Mobile-based nutrition education: Develop a mobile application or SMS-based platform that provides pregnant women with personalized nutrition education and reminders. This would allow women to access information and support at their convenience, even in remote areas with limited access to healthcare facilities.

2. Interactive multimedia resources: Create interactive videos or audiovisual materials that can be used during group education sessions to enhance the content and engagement. These resources can provide visual demonstrations, testimonials, and interactive quizzes to improve understanding and retention of nutrition information.

3. Training and mentorship programs for midwives: Implement comprehensive in-service training programs for midwives to enhance their knowledge and skills in providing maternal nutrition education. This could include workshops, seminars, and ongoing mentorship to ensure that midwives are equipped with the necessary tools to deliver effective nutrition education.

4. Strengthening infrastructure and resources: Improve the availability and accessibility of educational materials, such as posters, pamphlets, and visual aids, in antenatal clinics. Additionally, ensure that clinics have adequate facilities and resources to support nutrition education, such as demonstration kitchens or breastfeeding support rooms.

5. Integration of nutrition education into routine antenatal care: Increase the time allocated for nutrition education during antenatal care visits to ensure that pregnant women receive comprehensive and in-depth information. This could involve restructuring the clinic schedule or dedicating specific sessions solely for nutrition education.

6. Collaboration with community health workers: Engage community health workers to support and reinforce maternal nutrition education in the community. These workers can conduct home visits, organize community-based education sessions, and provide ongoing support and guidance to pregnant women.

7. Continuous monitoring and evaluation: Establish a system for monitoring and evaluating the effectiveness of maternal nutrition education interventions. This could involve regular assessments of knowledge and behavior change among pregnant women, as well as feedback from midwives and other healthcare providers to identify areas for improvement.

It is important to note that these recommendations are based on the specific context and findings of the study in Uganda. Further research and adaptation may be needed to ensure the relevance and effectiveness of these innovations in other settings.
AI Innovations Description
Based on the description provided, the recommendation to improve access to maternal health would be to enhance the maternal nutrition education provided by midwives in antenatal clinics. The study identified several deficiencies in the current nutrition education, including inadequate content and presentation, limited time allocated to nutrition education, and insufficient resources and support for midwives. To address these issues and promote effective nutrition education, the following recommendations can be implemented:

1. In-Service Training and Mentorship: Provide comprehensive in-service training programs for midwives on maternal nutrition. This training should cover the relevant guidelines, appropriate weight gain during pregnancy, healthy habits, avoidance of substance abuse, and nutrition precautions in special circumstances. Additionally, mentorship programs can be established to provide ongoing support and guidance to midwives in delivering effective nutrition education.

2. Resource Provision: Allocate resources to ensure that midwives have access to up-to-date and evidence-based educational materials on maternal nutrition. This includes providing pamphlets, brochures, posters, and other visual aids that reinforce key messages about healthy eating during pregnancy.

3. Infrastructure Improvement: Enhance the infrastructure of antenatal clinics to create a conducive environment for nutrition education. This may involve providing dedicated spaces for group education sessions, ensuring the availability of audio-visual equipment for interactive sessions, and improving the overall organization and layout of the clinic to facilitate efficient delivery of nutrition education.

4. Collaboration and Coordination: Foster collaboration between midwives, nutritionists, and other healthcare professionals involved in maternal health. This can help ensure a multidisciplinary approach to nutrition education and enable the sharing of expertise and resources.

5. Continuous Evaluation and Quality Improvement: Establish mechanisms for continuous evaluation of the effectiveness of maternal nutrition education programs. This can involve regular assessments of midwives’ knowledge and skills, feedback from pregnant women on the usefulness of the education received, and monitoring of outcomes related to maternal and infant health.

By implementing these recommendations, access to maternal health can be improved by providing pregnant women with comprehensive and evidence-based nutrition education, empowering midwives with the necessary knowledge and resources, and creating a supportive environment for effective education delivery.
AI Innovations Methodology
Based on the provided description, one potential innovation to improve access to maternal health is the development of a comprehensive maternal nutrition education program. This program would aim to address the deficiencies identified in the study, such as inadequate content and presentation of maternal nutrition, limited time allotted for nutrition education, and deficient resources and infrastructure.

The program could include the following recommendations:

1. Enhancing the content and depth of maternal nutrition education: Develop evidence-based educational materials and resources that cover a wide range of topics related to maternal nutrition, including appropriate weight gain during pregnancy, healthy habits, substance abuse avoidance, and nutrition precautions in special circumstances. Ensure that the education materials are culturally sensitive and accessible to all pregnant women.

2. Increasing the time allocated for nutrition education: Extend the duration of the routine antenatal education session to allow for more comprehensive coverage of maternal nutrition. Allocate sufficient time for midwives to deliver nutrition education to pregnant women individually or in small groups.

3. Improving the organization and delivery of nutrition education: Develop guidelines and protocols for delivering maternal nutrition education, ensuring consistency and standardization across all antenatal clinics. Provide training and mentorship to midwives to enhance their knowledge and skills in delivering effective nutrition education.

4. Strengthening resources and infrastructure: Provide adequate resources and information education and communication (IEC) materials at antenatal clinics to support maternal nutrition education. This may include posters, brochures, videos, and other visual aids that can be used during education sessions. Ensure that the clinic environment is conducive to education, with appropriate facilities and equipment.

To simulate the impact of these recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a methodology could be developed using a combination of quantitative and qualitative approaches. Here is a brief outline of a possible methodology:

1. Baseline data collection: Collect data on the current state of maternal nutrition education, including the content, duration, and resources available. This could involve surveys, interviews, and observations similar to the methods used in the study described.

2. Development and implementation of the intervention: Implement the recommended innovations in maternal nutrition education in selected antenatal clinics. This could involve training midwives, providing educational materials, and improving resources and infrastructure.

3. Monitoring and evaluation: Collect data on the implementation of the intervention, including the delivery of nutrition education, midwives’ adherence to guidelines, and the availability and use of resources. This could be done through observations, interviews, and document analysis.

4. Impact assessment: Measure the impact of the intervention on access to maternal health by comparing key indicators before and after the implementation. This could include indicators such as the knowledge and awareness of pregnant women regarding maternal nutrition, the uptake of recommended practices, and the overall satisfaction with the education received.

5. Qualitative analysis: Analyze qualitative data collected through interviews and observations to gain insights into the experiences and perceptions of pregnant women and midwives regarding the intervention. This could involve thematic analysis to identify common themes and patterns.

6. Reporting and dissemination: Summarize the findings of the impact assessment and qualitative analysis in a report or research paper. Share the results with relevant stakeholders, including policymakers, healthcare providers, and community members, to inform decision-making and further improvements in maternal health access.

It is important to note that this is just a brief description of a possible methodology and would need to be further developed and tailored to the specific context and resources available.

Partagez ceci :
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email