“I don’t want financial support but verbal support.” How do caregivers manage children’s access to and retention in HIV care in urban Zimbabwe?

listen audio

Study Justification:
This study aimed to inform the design of a community-based intervention to support caregivers of HIV-positive children in urban Zimbabwe. The study focused on understanding the factors that affect children’s access to and retention in HIV care. By identifying the facilitators and barriers experienced by caregivers, the study aimed to develop strategies to increase children’s retention in care.
Highlights:
– The study used an existing conceptual framework to assess the local contextual factors affecting children’s linkages to HIV care in Harare, Zimbabwe.
– Semi-structured interviews were conducted with primary caregivers of HIV-positive children and key informants from community-based organizations providing adherence support or related services.
– The study identified a range of facilitators and barriers, including distance to the hospital, cost of transportation, fear of disclosing HIV status, unstable family structure, and institutional factors such as drug stock-outs and healthcare worker absenteeism.
– Facilitators included openness within the family, availability of practical assistance, and psychosocial support from community members.
– The proposed decentralization of HIV care was found to be insufficient to ensure children’s sustained retention in care.
– Based on the study findings, a package of structured home visits by voluntary lay workers was developed to address determinants such as disclosure within families, access to available services, and support through caregivers’ social networks.
– A randomized controlled trial is currently underway to assess the impact of these interventions on children’s retention in care over two years.
Recommendations:
– Implement a community-based intervention that includes structured home visits by voluntary lay workers to support caregivers of HIV-positive children.
– Strengthen existing support mechanisms and integrate the intervention within these mechanisms to create synergy and improve access to care.
– Conduct a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of the intervention on children’s retention in care.
Key Role Players:
– Primary caregivers of HIV-positive children
– Community-based organizations providing adherence support or related services
– Voluntary lay workers
– Healthcare workers
– School personnel
– Policy makers
Cost Items for Planning Recommendations:
– Training and supervision of voluntary lay workers
– Transportation for home visits
– Communication and coordination with community-based organizations
– Development and dissemination of educational materials for caregivers
– Monitoring and evaluation of the intervention
– Research and data analysis for the randomized controlled trial

The strength of evidence for this abstract is 8 out of 10.
The evidence in the abstract is strong because it provides a clear description of the study design, methods, and findings. The study used an existing conceptual framework and conducted formative research to identify key factors affecting children’s linkages to HIV care in Zimbabwe. The study also identified facilitators and barriers experienced by caregivers. The abstract concludes with the development of a package of structured home visits and mentions an ongoing randomized controlled trial to assess impact. However, to improve the evidence, the abstract could provide more specific details about the sample size, data analysis methods, and limitations of the study.

Introduction: Children living with HIV experience particular challenges in accessing HIV care. Children usually rely on adult caregivers for access to care, including timely diagnosis, initiation of treatment and sustained engagement with HIV services. The aim of this study was to inform the design of a community-based intervention to support caregivers of HIV-positive children to increase children’s retention in care as part of a programme introducing decentralized HIV care in primary health facilities. Methods: Using an existing conceptual framework, we conducted formative research to identify key local contextual factors affecting children’s linkages to HIV care in Harare, Zimbabwe. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 primary caregivers of HIV-positive children aged 6-15 years enrolled at a hospital clinic for at least six months, followed by interviews with nine key informants from five community-based organizations providing adherence support or related services. Results: We identified a range of facilitators and barriers that caregivers experience. Distance to the hospital, cost of transportation, fear of disclosing HIV status to the child or others, unstable family structure and institutional factors such as drug stock-outs, healthcare worker absenteeism and unsympathetic school environments proved the most salient limiting factors. Facilitators included openness within the family, availability of practical assistance and psychosocial support from community members. Conclusions: The proposed decentralization of HIV care will mitigate concerns about distance and transport costs but is likely to be insufficient to ensure children’s sustained retention. Following this study, we developed a package of structured home visits by voluntary lay workers to proactively address other determinants such as disclosure within families, access to available services and support through caregivers’ social networks. A randomized controlled trial is underway to assess impact on children’s retention in care over two years. © 2014 Busza J et al; licensee International AIDS Society.

We used the Skovdal et al. [15] conceptual framework as an assessment tool, gathering information for each of its dimensions to build up a picture of locally salient material, symbolic, relational and institutional determinants of children’s retention in care. We also sought to identify and map existing community-based initiatives that provide adherence support or similar outreach to families of HIV-positive children to avoid duplication and integrate our intervention within available support mechanisms to create synergy and strengthen access. The study was conducted between October and November 2012 at the Harare Central Hospital HIV clinic, which has provided HIV diagnosis and care to children since the inception of the National Paediatric HIV treatment programme. Children who have been diagnosed with HIV are referred to this clinic for ART eligibility screening, initiation of treatment, and all follow-up care. Children continue to rely on the hospital for their clinical monitoring and ART drug supply until they transition to adult care. The hospital serves the same high-density suburbs in Harare that make up the catchment area of our planned intervention trial, making it likely that participants would reflect the socio-demographic profile, economic status, and living conditions of the trial communities. We conducted semi-structured interviews with primary caregivers of HIV-positive children aged 6–15 years enrolled at the clinic for at least six months, followed by interviews with key informants from any community-based organizations (CBO) mentioned by caregivers as providing adherence support or related services in the hospital’s catchment area. The 6–15 age group was selected because it includes children eligible for paediatric HIV care; younger children are the responsibility of maternal health programmes and those diagnosed after age 15 are classified as adults. Caregivers were sampled to reflect diversity by relationship to the child(ren) for whom they care, and background characteristics including age, sex, and residence. Interviews were conducted in a private room at the hospital while caregivers were waiting for an appointment. The topic guide addressed experiences of supporting children in health-seeking, diagnosis, disclosure (if applicable), attending regular appointments, undertaking medical tests, taking medication and positive living more broadly (mitigation of stigma, relationships at school, nutrition, psychosocial care, etc.) CBO key informants were interviewed at their workplace about the services they provided and their perceptions of how to successfully support adherence. All interviews were conducted in Shona by four fieldworkers (three female and one male) with prior qualitative research experience who were further trained on the study tools and helped to pilot them. Fieldworkers transcribed their own interviews and translated them into English. The first author conducted thematic data analysis that organized excerpts from interview transcripts into the four structured dimensions of the Skovdal et al. conceptual framework, allowing for additional categories to emerge directly from the data to create new dimensions or refine their attributes. Ethical approval for the study was granted by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (UK), Biomedical Research & Training Institute (Zimbabwe), the Medical Research Council of Zimbabwe and the Harare Hospital Ethics Committee. Fieldworkers obtained written informed consent from all study participants prior to interview and emphasized that enrolment would not affect access to services at Harare Hospital.

Based on the provided description, it seems that the study is focused on identifying and addressing barriers to children’s access and retention in HIV care in urban Zimbabwe. The study aims to inform the design of a community-based intervention to support caregivers of HIV-positive children.

In terms of potential innovations to improve access to maternal health, based on the limited information provided, it is difficult to make specific recommendations. However, here are some general innovations that could potentially be considered:

1. Mobile health (mHealth) interventions: Utilizing mobile technology to provide information, reminders, and support to caregivers of HIV-positive children. This could include text messages or mobile applications that provide guidance on medication adherence, appointment reminders, and access to resources.

2. Community health workers: Training and deploying community health workers who can provide support and education to caregivers in their own communities. These workers could help address barriers such as transportation costs and distance to healthcare facilities by providing services closer to home.

3. Peer support networks: Establishing peer support networks for caregivers of HIV-positive children, where they can share experiences, provide emotional support, and exchange information on accessing and retaining HIV care. This could be done through support groups or online communities.

4. Integrated services: Integrating HIV care services with other maternal and child health services, such as antenatal care and immunization programs. This could help streamline access to care and ensure that caregivers have comprehensive support for their children’s health needs.

5. Health education and awareness campaigns: Conducting targeted health education campaigns to raise awareness about the importance of HIV care for children and address stigma and discrimination. These campaigns could be conducted through various channels, including community events, media, and social media.

It is important to note that these recommendations are general and may need to be tailored to the specific context and needs of the population in urban Zimbabwe. Further research and consultation with local stakeholders would be necessary to determine the most appropriate innovations for improving access to maternal health in this setting.
AI Innovations Description
The study described in the provided text aimed to inform the design of a community-based intervention to support caregivers of HIV-positive children in Zimbabwe. The goal was to increase children’s retention in care as part of a program introducing decentralized HIV care in primary health facilities. The study used an existing conceptual framework to identify key local contextual factors affecting children’s access to and retention in HIV care.

The study conducted semi-structured interviews with primary caregivers of HIV-positive children aged 6-15 years enrolled at a hospital clinic for at least six months. Interviews were also conducted with key informants from community-based organizations providing adherence support or related services. The interviews addressed various aspects of supporting children in health-seeking, diagnosis, disclosure, attending appointments, taking medication, and positive living.

The study identified several facilitators and barriers that caregivers experience in accessing and retaining HIV care for their children. The most salient limiting factors included distance to the hospital, cost of transportation, fear of disclosing HIV status, unstable family structure, and institutional factors such as drug stock-outs and healthcare worker absenteeism. Facilitators included openness within the family, availability of practical assistance, and psychosocial support from community members.

Based on the findings, the study proposed a package of structured home visits by voluntary lay workers to proactively address determinants such as disclosure within families, access to available services, and support through caregivers’ social networks. A randomized controlled trial is currently underway to assess the impact of this intervention on children’s retention in care over two years.

Overall, the study provides valuable insights into the challenges faced by caregivers in accessing and retaining HIV care for children in Zimbabwe. The proposed intervention aims to address these challenges and improve access to maternal health services.
AI Innovations Methodology
The study mentioned in the description aims to inform the design of a community-based intervention to support caregivers of HIV-positive children in urban Zimbabwe, with the goal of increasing children’s retention in HIV care. The study used the Skovdal et al. conceptual framework as an assessment tool to identify key local contextual factors affecting children’s access to and retention in HIV care. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with primary caregivers of HIV-positive children aged 6-15 years enrolled at a hospital clinic for at least six months. Key informants from community-based organizations providing adherence support or related services were also interviewed.

The methodology used in the study involved the following steps:

1. Selection of participants: Primary caregivers of HIV-positive children aged 6-15 years enrolled at the hospital clinic for at least six months were selected as participants. Caregivers were sampled to reflect diversity by relationship to the child(ren) and background characteristics such as age, sex, and residence.

2. Data collection: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with the selected caregivers. The interviews addressed various aspects of supporting children in health-seeking, diagnosis, disclosure, attending appointments, taking medication, and positive living. Key informants from community-based organizations were also interviewed about the services they provided and their perceptions of successful adherence support.

3. Data analysis: The interviews were transcribed and translated into English. Thematic data analysis was conducted by the first author, organizing excerpts from the interview transcripts into the four dimensions of the Skovdal et al. conceptual framework: material, symbolic, relational, and institutional determinants. Additional categories were allowed to emerge from the data, creating new dimensions or refining their attributes.

4. Ethical considerations: Ethical approval for the study was obtained from relevant institutions. Fieldworkers obtained written informed consent from all study participants, emphasizing that enrollment would not affect access to services at the hospital.

The findings of the study identified a range of facilitators and barriers that caregivers experience in accessing and retaining HIV care for children. These findings will inform the design of a community-based intervention to address these factors and improve access to maternal health.

In terms of innovations to improve access to maternal health, based on the information provided, it is not directly related to maternal health but focuses on children’s access to and retention in HIV care. However, some potential recommendations to improve access to maternal health could include:

1. Strengthening antenatal care services: Enhancing the quality and availability of antenatal care services can improve access to maternal health. This can include providing comprehensive prenatal care, promoting early and regular prenatal visits, and ensuring access to essential maternal health services such as screenings, vaccinations, and counseling.

2. Community-based interventions: Implementing community-based interventions can help overcome barriers to accessing maternal health services. This can involve training and deploying community health workers to provide maternal health education, support, and referrals within the community. It can also include establishing mobile clinics or outreach programs to reach remote or underserved areas.

3. Telemedicine and digital health solutions: Utilizing telemedicine and digital health solutions can improve access to maternal health, especially in areas with limited healthcare infrastructure. This can involve providing remote consultations, telemonitoring of high-risk pregnancies, and delivering health information and reminders through mobile applications or SMS.

4. Addressing socio-cultural barriers: Recognizing and addressing socio-cultural barriers that prevent women from accessing maternal health services is crucial. This can involve community engagement and education programs to challenge harmful cultural practices, promoting gender equality, and empowering women to make informed decisions about their health.

To simulate the impact of these recommendations on improving access to maternal health, a methodology could involve:

1. Baseline data collection: Collecting data on the current state of access to maternal health services, including indicators such as the number of antenatal care visits, facility deliveries, maternal mortality rates, and barriers faced by women in accessing care.

2. Intervention implementation: Implementing the recommended interventions in selected areas or communities. This can involve training healthcare providers, establishing community-based programs, deploying telemedicine solutions, and conducting awareness campaigns.

3. Monitoring and evaluation: Continuously monitoring and evaluating the impact of the interventions on access to maternal health services. This can include tracking changes in the indicators mentioned earlier, conducting surveys or interviews with women to assess their experiences, and gathering feedback from healthcare providers and community members.

4. Comparative analysis: Comparing the data collected after the intervention with the baseline data to determine the impact of the recommendations on improving access to maternal health. This can involve statistical analysis, identifying trends or patterns, and assessing the effectiveness of the interventions in addressing the identified barriers.

By following this methodology, policymakers and healthcare providers can gain insights into the effectiveness of the recommended innovations in improving access to maternal health and make informed decisions on scaling up successful interventions.

Partagez ceci :
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email